Photographer's Note
Terrible title, I know. Somehow, I am not feeling too inspired at the moment. To be honest, I am sitting here with a deep personal trouble. What next?
Experiences should make us better people. If we walk away, having taken a few pictures and going back to the same humdrum treadmill, without thought of what we once felt...well, what does it actually mean on the grand scheme of things? Does it even matter?
What does it mean to you? At least you don't have to collect rubbish for a living. Having money to go to the pub is a blessing. I know this much now.
So, what next...I don't have a clue.
oh, the woman closest to us and the young girl are mother/daughter. They are waiting to see how much they have earned today. Those are scales, used to weigh up the huge bags of rubbish, weighing upto 25kilos each.
Project: Underexposed - Lights in Dark Spaces
luisafonso, broglia, prantik, bhorerpakhi, designsoul, KevRyan marcou esta nota como útil
Critiques | Translate
Furachan
(0) 2007-07-17 3:04
Briliant compo, Kaj, with real depth and this painterly feeling throughout. It is vy far one of your best compositions - real flair shown here for the fynamics of a group, not just individual well lit portraits which are, welll...easier. This has a Sohrab touch to it for sure!
Bravo, really...
Francis
michiels
(4170) 2007-07-17 3:08
hello Kajal,
i love the play of sunlight in the scene, makes it dreamy ... a wonderfull daily life scene from India!
many greetings, inn ;)
ps. "keep your mind up" like we say in Belgium, it is difficult to say the correct things but know that you can escape a moment in the photos and that people care about you !!! ;))
sidstakes
(772) 2007-07-17 3:51
Isn't the kid the very same in this photo you posted earlier..
What I like about this photograph is that your presence is completely wiped out from this photograph...it seems like something in the shop was set up to take this picture... :)
everlasting
(19680) 2007-07-17 3:55
Kaj, you seem as if you are suffering from reversed cultural shock, I am not saying this flippantly - I know that when you go through an experience such as you have had and have witnessed going back to the humdrum life takes soem getting used to - you ask what is the point - others around are constanly complaining and you just want to say - eh hold up, if only you knew, but then again they wouldnt understand.
Dont be too hard on yourself, it takes time to put everything in perspective again. Get back into balance - maybe not such a bad title after all.
The play with lighting its delicious here almost an oil painting.
luisafonso
(862) 2007-07-17 5:49
Your photos are always so intimate, so inside the people's soul... Another perfect example about your ability to manage light, to perfectly play with shadows. It's easy to understand why you live these people life so close to your heart. We really get the feeling that you're not an intrusive element here, but more a person that shares their drama. It's not easy to put things in perspective when you leave them and get back to a more "just" world, but you really have to try. Great post.
broglia
(3604) 2007-07-17 6:13
Beautiful shot Kaj, you are so at one with these hardworking women. It would have been so much easier for you to have taken the shot from the outside looking in - but that would not be the Kaj way. You are always there alongside them.
I think Elaine's words are very true, it's difficult to return to the comforts of home, remembering the daily toil of the women you've left behind.
The lighting on the young girl is stunning, and such a wonderful expression. The man I recognize from a previous shot. I agree with Francis, a truly superb group shot.
Very best wishes, Roberto
prantik
(1136) 2007-07-17 6:14
Good post Kajal. As Sidhartha pointed out you are a detached observer in this picture which is a refreshing break from your previous pictures which are all excellent. Your post-India existentialist ennui is highly understandable. The calendar picture of the yogi or Buddha somewhat anchors your note.
Best regards
P
bhorerpakhi
(559) 2007-07-17 7:48
Oh great, this has class written all over it. What can I say, only wish I could take photos such as this. Whatever your personal problems are I hope you get over them quickly and continue to enthrall us with such beautiful images.
Poulomi
BrianGraney
(1740) 2007-07-17 15:00
I can't remember the title of the painting that this brings to mind.....but it's certainly an intimate depiction of some reality.
Maybe the most important thing about coming back is to remember what you have seen and tell the stories that need to be told - and that's what you are doing with such skill and compassion.
Brian
designsoul
(17843) 2007-07-18 9:50
An absolutely gorgeous, intimate if sad scene. The light like in Rembrandt's beautiful Nativity or Rest on the Flight to Egypt oils--transcendental. But here, weighing rubbish. The weight of the world... the plight of so many less privileged. And yet, there is the picture of the Buddha (?) on their calendar. And perhaps a certain tender aquiescence and acceptance in their hearts. It certainly does hit us, going to pubs or buying new shoes...
Your recent shots hit me on the heart. They are powerful, very powerful, Kaj.
Hope your deep personal trouble will lift or has already lifted... but as you write, our experiences are the most integral nourishments for our understanding--as long as we are not running away from them. And I doubt that you do, that you actually are able to. That is what comes through your shots. A certain belonging, oneness.
take care,
sasa
Luko
(14000) 2007-07-23 6:09
What gorgeous lighting you had there, your kajal spiceship... your composition is getting a little more complex than the usual with an excellent balance, I guess this is where the title comes from... and, guess what, I wouldn't mind converting it to BW. (Calm down please, I didn't say RGB wasn't appropriate, I simply mention that I grant you the right to convert it. ;D ...)
I agree with Francis it's closer to Sohrab than the usual kajalesque production (not saying it's better, I am simply noticing it's different)... on a personnal side I feel a little closer to this sort.
The only flaw I would point at this stage is the probably too glaring area on the guy's white sleeve. Other than that it would be perfection.
PierreMorel
(1172) 2007-07-24 14:19
Nice shot!
With very difficult lightning condition, you got a pretty good capture and composition is interesting.
Regards,
Pierre
pradip (364) 2007-07-25 1:20
hi Kajal
Interesting subject..Well conceived ..Well taken.
Colour,Contrast,brightness are all perfect.
Pradip
nicoz
(1979) 2007-07-26 7:17
Hi!
A well balanced photo, ok, sorry...
Gorgeous light and compo. It's like we are standing there, looking at this man like they're all doing. So, how much???
Cool photo!
Nicolas
Photo Information
-
Copyright: Kajal Nisha Patel (kajspice)
(4542)
- Genre: Pessoas
- Medium: Cor
- Date Taken: 2007-05-00
- Categories: Vida Diária
- Camera: Canon EOS 350D, Canon EFS 18-55mm f3.5-5.6, Skylight 1B
- Versão da Foto: Versão Original
- Tema(s): Underexposed: Lights in Dark Spaces, Sasa's Favourites, 200-300 [view contributor(s)]
- Date Submitted: 2007-07-17 2:22
- Favoritos: 2 [ver]
Discussions
- To sidstakes: the girl... (1)
by kajspice, last updated 2007-07-17 02:24 - To BrianGraney: please... (1)
by kajspice, last updated 2007-07-17 04:45